In this instance, the AD was looking for some eye-catching artwork for their cover. It had not been decided which article was going to grace the cover, so we worked on ideas for the two possibilities. One feature was about Unions/Big Labor and the other is about the military heroes of Small Business. Here are the sketches:

The first sketch for the "small business soldier" was a very simple man-in-suit with stars on his lapels and a striped tie, looking heroic and patriotic. Although I enjoy the sketch as a drawing, I feel this was too subtle.

The second sketch has a better feel. They wanted a superhero-type image similar to the Blue-collar football image I had done a few months back. I feel that a patriotic superhero costume has been perfected, so I alluded the the amazing Captain America.

The second article dealt with the effect of labor unions on small business owners. In today's tough economy, some already suffering businesses are on thin ice because of union-enforced regulations that may or may not relate to their business and employees. For the first, sketch I went with a laborer's gloved hand squeezing a small businessman.

My second sketch played off a "boxing in" phrase used in the article in reference to government and labor unions trying to make small businesses fit a generic mold of what all businesses should be and how they should perform, what they should provide, etc.

We were surprised when the higher-ups decided to run the Unions/Big Labor article as the cover; the AD was almost certain when initially contacting me that they were going to run the Soldier article, and I thought the best sketch was the superhero concept. It was decided to go with the squeezing sketch while dropping the suit (yes!) and adding a female. With this type of work, it is always a consideration to portray multiple nationalities and both sexes. I got into the revision and even added a third figure for a better balance and composition.

I submitted two versions, and the AD chose the limited color palette. I always enjoy her type layouts over my images. With this illustration, I tried to plan for her use of white text and as such limited my own use of lighter values. All in all, I think we collaborated on a striking cover that grab's attention (no pun intended).
The article is a pretty interesting read, especially when taking into account union effects on businesses with only a few employees that have to meet these "large business union" demands.
Enjoy the Day,
Chris
chris-whetzel.com